Campus ID News
Card, mobile credential, payment and security
library id image 1 e1643136438698

Is library ID keeping up with times?

Card security questionable as checkout extends to laptops, tablets

Andrew Hudson   ||   Jun 03, 2015  ||   ,

The library – a university service as old as academia itself – has long afforded students the ability to check out materials to be returned in a timely fashion. At least that’s traditionally been the idea.

Over time, however, the resources students need to complete their coursework have evolved, and in many cases their value has skyrocketed.

At Philadelphia’s Drexel University and other campus libraries across the country, students can check out expensive equipment such as laptops and tablets. With such valuable materials available, questions arise with the security of the patron ID process in the modern library.

To check out these coveted devices, are students required to do anything more than swipe a card or hold it under the red glow of a bar code scanner?

A 2002 CR80News article on library patron ID explored how mag stripes seemed to be replacing bar codes as the gold standard for library identification. After nearly 15 years and the arrival of newer and more secure card technologies, it seems logical that things would once again have progressed. But are new technologies being used to drive credentials into library systems today?

“Although a large portion of libraries continue to use the bar code to retrieve patron data for book check out, we are seeing an increase in alternate technologies,” says Fred Emery, Heartland OneCard director of sales.

Contactless is making inroads at the library, says Kent Pawlak, Blackboard Transact’s director of product strategy. “There are still many libraries that request bar code on a card, but that is decreasing as they accept contactless and other identity verification methods,” he adds.

Still, bar codes are the tool of choice at the vast majority of libraries, says Grey Bartholomew, product manager for Odyssey PCS and Odyssey Direct at CBORD. “Anecdotally I would say 95-98% of our campuses are using bar code, 2-5% mag stripe and virtually none are using prox or contactless.”

Heartland’s Emery concurs, citing that about 85% of the company’s clients still use bar code, 10% use mag stripe and about 5% use some form of contactless technology.

Bartholomew believes that it less about universities opting for bar code than simply going with what they know. “I would say that bar code has been the standard for so long that campuses – library management specifically – takes the path of least resistance and sticks with what they know,” he explains. “However, campus card professionals see the benefits of card technology standardization and are beginning to educate library managers on other options.”

The example of checking out laptops and tablets is crucial to this education because it stresses the value of the materials that students have access to using their campus card.

While a vast majority will utilize a service like this properly and return the gear, the worst-case scenario could paint a very different picture. Suppose a student decided to produce counterfeit cards with valid identification numbers and use them to check out and resell expensive equipment.

Reign of the bar code

The long-standing king of library check out remains the bar code. But it is an inherently insecure technology designed to expedite data entry and reduce human data input errors. Common bar codes are based on standardized symbologies so there is nothing secret or obscure about library codes, nor are they difficult to reproduce. Much like type fonts, most bar code formats are available for download online.

“Bar codes are primarily used to identify check-out materials, and as a result, every circulation station already has a bar code scanner,” says Pawlak. “The use of bar codes on cards at libraries has primarily been due to the simple fact that the reader was readily available.”

Over time, however, more libraries discovered that they could identify the patron in a different manner than the one they use identify books and materials. This realization, according to Pawlak, ushered in the acceptance of other card technologies.

“One driving factor is security. Bar codes are readily duplicable, providing for higher risk of fraud,” explains Pawlak. Additionally, the need for a bar code is often outweighed by the valuable card real estate it requires and the few demands for it beyond the library.

As for those valuable checkout materials, it seems that universities may be taking notice of the vulnerabilities of the bar code. “Quite often we see use of patron ID solutions other than the bar code – mag stripe or contactless – for check out of non-book items, such as laptops and AV equipment, particularly if the items are being managed in a system outside of the one used to check out books,” says Emery.

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter


Sheridan College onecard banner
Sep 21, 23 / ,

Interview: Sheridan College onecard manager details hugely successful mobile credential rollout

At the start of the fall term in 2022, the Sheridan College onecard office rolled out its new Mobile onecard. The Canadian institution serves 27,000 students across its three campuses in Ontario, so launching a project of this magnitude required careful planning and a well-orchestrated marketing effort to ensure success. CampusIDNews spoke with Aesha Brown, […]
University of Minnesota Twin Cities mascot
Sep 21, 23 /

Treasure hunt sends students in search of mascot’s lost campus card

At the University of Minnesota Twin Cities, the mission is to find Goldy’s U Card. On each of the institution’s three campuses, one of the mascot’s U Cards is hidden. Each undergraduate student that finds a card will receive a $100 reward. Finding the cards will not be easy. To help in the hunt, three […]
UX Tech event logo
Sep 19, 23 / ,

ColorID’s UX Tech event explores campus ID impact on user experience

We all want great user experiences for our cardholders and our system administrators, and advancements in technology are making this more possible than ever before. New credential and reader technologies are transforming the campus ID and with it the campus. The event is hosted and sponsored by UC Irvine, and will take place at the […]
CIDN logo reversed
The only publication dedicated to the use of campus cards, mobile credentials, identity and security technology in the education market. CampusIDNews – formerly CR80News – has served more than 6,500 subscribers for more than two decades.

Join us, @NACCUorg, and @TouchNet to explore how campus card programs can successfully navigate the sales and procurement process. Join the webinar on June 6, 2 pm EDT.

Webinar: Learn how the University of Arizona uses campus cards, mobile ordering, kiosks, lockers, and robots to revolutionize campus dining. April 7, 2-2:30 EDT. Register Now at

Load More...
CampusIDNews is published by AVISIAN Publishing
315 E. Georgia St.
Tallahassee, FL 32301[email protected]
Use our contact form to submit tips, corrections, or questions to our team.
©2023 CampusIDNews. All rights reserved.