Campus ID News
Card, mobile credential, payment and security
slider DataMinig 1

Data mining the campus card system

Card data can refine services and identify at-risk students, but privacy concerns abound

Andrew Hudson   ||   Aug 02, 2016  ||   , ,

People tend to break into a cold sweat when they hear the term “data mining.” It’s a sensitive topic in a digital age – for good reason – and it’s perhaps one of the most complex issues that any industry has to face, higher education included.

Every institution with a campus card system is, right now, sitting on a veritable mountain of data. Every touch point where the student ID card is used across the campus and beyond – payments, dorm and building access, event ticketing and so on – yields a data point. The more data points, the clearer the picture becomes.

The data accrued by contemporary campus card systems can be used to refine campus services and business operations. It can also help to identify potentially at-risk students through attendance, access control or transaction trends. Whatever the application, however, the decision to data mine a campus card system won’t come without considerable debate.

That is because the concept of data mining is controversial. While the practice isn’t inherently evil, it is dependent upon its execution. If done responsibly and with the proper oversight, there’s great potential to benefit both institutions and students alike. But to onlookers – including many students, staff and faculty – data mining is quick to be labeled privacy invasive and Big Brother-esque.

Building a foundation

The analysis or mining of card system data is not a new concept.

“I first realized potential in 2004 after reading early studies that used university email metadata to map and analyze social interactions on campus,” says Matt Pittinsky, CEO of Parchment, Inc. and assistant research professor at Arizona State University. As a co-founder of Blackboard Inc., Pittinsky saw the vast potential of student information and card system data, and after leaving the company he conducted academic research on the topic.

[pullquote]Analysis of card system data can show indicators of student engagement and retention. But equally important is whether it can be tackled with proper anonymity.[/pullquote]

“It occurred to me that social interaction could be inferred from patterns between any two individuals on a campus and that physical co-presence and email interaction together could go even further,” explains Pittinsky.

These patterns help to form the framework for what can be gleaned from card system data. Pittinsky saw that analysis of card system data could be an indicator of student engagement and retention. “But equally important for me was whether it could be tackled with proper anonymity protections,” he explains.

Insights that can be gleaned from card data run a wide gamut. “First and foremost, business analytics can help a campus understand its use of physical resources, enabling auxiliary services to maximize performance,” he explains.

Student benefits of data mining

At a high level, Heartland OneCard’s director of sales, Fred Emery, highlights three key student-facing benefits to mining card system data:

  1. Enhance student experience. Tracking access enables proper staffing and hours of operations to handle the bursts of activity.
  2. Identify at-risk students. Anticipating at-risk students to proactively keep them engaged before dropping could be a valuable service for students. This could also help in reducing receivables as well.
  3. Engage students. Analyzing trends and behaviors enables the creation of programs to further engage all students. This can keep students active throughout their college lifecycle and beyond as alumni.

But it also extends to individual students. Finding patterns or changes in patterns of behavior could hint to problems that might impact participation or even student safety.

From an institutional perspective, there’s an unspoken charter to help students progress through their academic pursuits and matriculate. That should be the goal. Campuses can view data interpretation as an opportunity to help meet this goal, so long as they remain transparent about what they’re doing with data and how they’re going about it, he suggests.

The key advances in this area are in the tools and methods used to analyze data, rather than the card systems themselves, Pittinsky says. “It’s much easier to analyze flat file data structures and work with very large record sizes now compared to the mid 2000s.”

Extending trust to new data types

“The relationship between a student and their institution has to be one of inherent trust and that trust must extend to the use of data for analytics,” says Jeff Staples, vice president of market development for Blackboard Transact.

Any institution that utilizes a credential system to grant access to facilities, services and privileges is by default generating data that could be used to better serve the institution’s mission, its students and the student experience, explains Staples. “That said, the volume of data is not what’s most important – it’s about leveraging actionable data to drive better outcomes.”

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter


Sheridan College onecard banner
Sep 21, 23 / ,

Interview: Sheridan College onecard manager details hugely successful mobile credential rollout

At the start of the fall term in 2022, the Sheridan College onecard office rolled out its new Mobile onecard. The Canadian institution serves 27,000 students across its three campuses in Ontario, so launching a project of this magnitude required careful planning and a well-orchestrated marketing effort to ensure success. CampusIDNews spoke with Aesha Brown, […]
University of Minnesota Twin Cities mascot
Sep 21, 23 /

Treasure hunt sends students in search of mascot’s lost campus card

At the University of Minnesota Twin Cities, the mission is to find Goldy’s U Card. On each of the institution’s three campuses, one of the mascot’s U Cards is hidden. Each undergraduate student that finds a card will receive a $100 reward. Finding the cards will not be easy. To help in the hunt, three […]
UX Tech event logo
Sep 19, 23 / ,

ColorID’s UX Tech event explores campus ID impact on user experience

We all want great user experiences for our cardholders and our system administrators, and advancements in technology are making this more possible than ever before. New credential and reader technologies are transforming the campus ID and with it the campus. The event is hosted and sponsored by UC Irvine, and will take place at the […]
CIDN logo reversed
The only publication dedicated to the use of campus cards, mobile credentials, identity and security technology in the education market. CampusIDNews – formerly CR80News – has served more than 6,500 subscribers for more than two decades.

Join us, @NACCUorg, and @TouchNet to explore how campus card programs can successfully navigate the sales and procurement process. Join the webinar on June 6, 2 pm EDT.

Webinar: Learn how the University of Arizona uses campus cards, mobile ordering, kiosks, lockers, and robots to revolutionize campus dining. April 7, 2-2:30 EDT. Register Now at

Load More...
CampusIDNews is published by AVISIAN Publishing
315 E. Georgia St.
Tallahassee, FL 32301[email protected]
Use our contact form to submit tips, corrections, or questions to our team.
©2023 CampusIDNews. All rights reserved.