Campus ID News
Card, mobile credential, payment and security
FEATURED
PARTNERS

New study suggests declining balance programs, declining in relevance

Joint study by Colorado State and NACCU finds 'closed' payment systems losing traction with students

CampusIDNews Staff   ||   Oct 23, 2024  ||   ,

 

Is a closed-system declining balance program necessary in a world where virtually every student shows up to campus with one or more debit or credit cards? Neal Lujan, director of the RamCard Office at Colorado State University thought a lot about this question when he initiated the NACCU declining balance survey.

His office runs RamCash, Colorado State’s successful declining balance program with 27,500 active accounts, 23 on-campus merchants, and $2.6 million in sales.

But does it cover costs, and more importantly, does it still provide benefit to students.

In recent years, a number of high profile institutions including Harvard have ended their declining balance program. But is that right for other institutions?

To help answer these questions, Lujan approached NACCU to see if they might collaborate on a research project to evaluate the current state of declining balance programs on campus.

The reasons given by the 50% of respondents reporting a decline include an increase in the use of other payment options, pandemic related impacts, reduced incentives for program use, and administrative overhead (e.g. costs).

NACCU agreed, and together they launched the NACCU declining balance survey in June 2024. Approximately 400 of the association’s primary members were invited to participate and nearly one-third returned responses.

Lujan and NACCU CEO Dawn Thomas presented the results of the survey in recent webinar.

Below are some of the highlights.

General info about declining balance programs

54% of campuses allow the tender to be used with both on and off campus merchants, while 46% restrict it to on campus merchants.

One-third of respondents dedicated between one and three FTEs to the program.

Merchant transaction fees or participation rates range from 3% to 32% of transaction value. 14% charge nothing to merchants

Costs and impacts on declining balance programs

Only one-third of campuses track costs related to the program, and of those that do, 43% do not cover their operating costs.

Half of schools support mobile wallet payments (not internal mobile credentials but Apple Wallet, etc.). Of those that do, 40% said that adding this additional payment option negatively impacted their program.

On the other hand, of the 45% of campuses that offer online ordering via Grubhub, Uber Eats, or Door Dash, nearly 60% reported a positive increase in declining balance sales.

Current state of programs

Half said their program is declining, 39% rebounding post-pandemic, and 11% said it is growing.

The reasons given by the 50% of respondents reporting a decline include an increase in the use of other payment options, pandemic related impacts, reduced incentives for program use, and administrative overhead (e.g. costs).

For the one in ten that reported their program was growing, reasons cited include partnerships with high-profile names like Starbucks and Grubhub, increased vendor participation off campus from national brands, and new services like laundry mandated via declining balance.

Lessons learned from the NACCU declining balance survey

“We did our own analysis of what the survey data told us,” says Lujan. “Understanding the mandatory operating costs to evaluate how well a program can be self-sustaining will be a focus as we continue our evaluation.”

He also suggests that growing income in ways that mutually benefit participating merchants and account holders will be a focus.

Finally, he says, evaluating the impacts and the opportunities related to mobile will be key. By mobile, he means the impacts on RamCash for both a potential move to mobile credentials as well as the competition posed by mobile wallet payments.

The webinar concluded with a 20-minute Q&A with attendees discussing the state of their campus declining balance programs. It is a session well worth a watch for any higher ed administration involved with closed system payments.

To watch the full session, click the image at the top of this page.

Related Posts

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter

RECENT ARTICLES

Mobile credential buy-in video image
Dec 05, 24 / ,

Key steps to get buy-in for mobile credentials on your campus

  In this episode of CampusIDNews Chats we explore how to get buy-in for mobile credentials on your campus and lay the groundwork with your colleagues and administration. Our guest Tim Nyblom, Director of End User Business Development for Higher Education for HID Global, starts with the concept of university branding. But often the ID […]
Penn State Go mobile app
Dec 05, 24 / ,

Penn State moves to Transact Mobile Ordering

After years of experience and a variety of mobile ordering solutions, Penn State is transitioning to the Transact Mobile Ordering app. At the institution’s main location – the University Park campus – a number of dining locations have already launched the service. All on-campus locations will be up and running by spring according to an […]
Spreadsheet
Dec 04, 24 /

UConn card office's recently published budget shows declining revenues

Like other institutions, University of Connecticut students pay mandatory fees to fund various non-academic programs and services. One of these fees, UConn’s General University Fee, helps support the One Card Office as well as Recreational Services, the performing arts center, Student Activities, the Student Union, and more. The General University Fee for the 2024/2025 academic […]
CIDN logo reversed
The only publication dedicated to the use of campus cards, mobile credentials, identity and security technology in the education market. CampusIDNews – formerly CR80News – has served more than 6,500 subscribers for more than two decades.
Twitter

Attn: friends in the biometrics space. Nominations close Friday for the annual Women in Biometrics Awards. Take five minutes to recognize a colleague or even yourself. http://WomenInBiometrics.com

Feb. 1 webinar explores how mobile ordering enhanced campus life, increased sales at UVA and Central Washington @Grubhub @CBORD

Load More...
Contact
CampusIDNews is published by AVISIAN Publishing
315 E. Georgia St.
Tallahassee, FL 32301
www.AVISIAN.com[email protected]
Use our contact form to submit tips, corrections, or questions to our team.
©2024 CampusIDNews. All rights reserved.